How I did it: My house remodel

September 04, 2019

Homeowners Gary and Jackie Weber got creative with their financing to build an addition onto their 1950s story-and-a-half house in Minnesota.

“How I Did It” features real consumer stories about achieving goals through financial planning and preparedness.

 

Gary and Jackie Weber bought their 1950s story-and-a-half home in St. Anthony, Minnesota, in 2004. They didn’t have many plans for the house, but they did know remodeling might be a possibility down the road. It would be six years, however, before the couple seriously started talking about an addition. And then another six years before they broke ground on the project.

 

“I’ve always wanted to do something like this,” says Gary, “not just to make more space for a family, but to also take this old building and make it our own and make it beautiful.” He and Jackie briefly window-shopped for new, larger homes to make sure they were considering all of their options. But the reasons they fell in love with the house in the first place—the character, quality of the construction, neighborhood and proximity to both Minneapolis and St. Paul—solidified their decision to remodel.

 

In 2014, the Webers hired a company to start sketching a design that would allow room to accommodate a growing family while maintaining a more traditional aesthetic to fit with the neighborhood’s architecture. The main goal? Maximize the upstairs space by designing a bump-out to hold the master suite, complete with a new bathroom.

 

Financing for a home renovation loan

Construction officially began in 2016, but financially planning for the project started long before with “a lot of strategic choices in the 10 years leading up to the remodel,” Gary says. Selling their previous house for a profit made it possible for the Webers to offer a strong down payment on their St. Anthony home. And a refinance in 2011 to a 15-year mortgage allowed them to make a large dent in the principal amount owed. After learning the estimated costs of the addition, they refinanced again in 2016, securing a renovation loan through a 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage.

 

Refinancing via a renovation loan lets borrowers roll remodeling costs into a new mortgage. These loans take into account the value of a home after a renovation so homeowners are able to borrow more than they could with a traditional home equity loan. Plus, refinancing loans often come with a caveat – you must borrow an additional amount equivalent to 20 percent of the project cost for unexpected expenses. This stipulation came in handy when the Webers’ renovations didn’t exactly go according to plan.

 

Unexpected home remodel costs

The porch was not structurally sound enough to hold the additional weight of a bump-out on the back of the house. So the contractor suggested tearing off the entire half story and rebuilding it with custom trusses. Trusses are an assembly of beams used to create a rigid structure. The siding also had to be completely redone once some damaged stucco was discovered. This created an opportune time to replace all windows and doors, plus add more insulation to the house’s exterior walls while everything was exposed.

 

On top of these construction setbacks, Jackie was in her first trimester of her second pregnancy. And she ended up needing emergency abdominal surgery at nine weeks. “So it was not just house-related, but a whole life surprise. An unexpected expense that was in the middle of a house renovation project,” Jackie says. “Mentally, it helped to know there was an end in sight. We also had a lot of support from friends and family, and that was key.”

 

How did it all turn out?

Being financially prepared was equally important. The Webers entered the project with a buffer, thanks, in part, to the 20 percent borrowing surplus required with their renovation loan. When that was used up, they cashed in a savings bond and tapped a Roth IRA to finish the remodel. They also eliminated unnecessary design features, such as a mudroom, to make up for some of the expenses.

 

While the addition ended up costing about 50 percent more than anticipated, “the nice thing about a lot of these unexpected expenses is that they really contributed to a much better end product,” Gary explains.

 

Beyond budgeting for a cost overrun – which Gary notes is not a matter of “if,” but “when” and “what” – the couple has a few bits of advice. They encourage other homeowners contemplating a remodel to get quotes from no less than three contractors. And don’t just go with the cheapest one.

 

“We went with someone we had the best connection with,” Jackie says. “These people are going to be in your home every single day for months. You have to be able to have a good rapport with them.”

 

Depending on the scale of the renovation and your budget, she also suggests considering alternative living arrangements during construction. This was something the Webers didn’t do and found challenging, especially with a three-year-old at home and another baby on the way.

 

In March 2017, two months before their second son arrived, the Webers were settled into their reimagined home. Despite the setbacks and unexpected costs, they agree it was all worth it in the end.

 

“We made the investment because we wanted to stay here. It’s a great school district, we love the neighborhood and the property that we’re on has a nice-sized lawn,” Jackie says. “We’re going to be here a while.”

 

Are you thinking of updating or remodeling your home? Ask these questions before you hire a contractor.

Related content

What financial advice would you give your younger self?

10 ways to increase your home’s curb appeal

DIY home projects 101: tips from a first-timer

Evaluating interest rate risk creating risk management strategy

Car shopping: Buying versus leasing your next vehicle

What you should know about buying a car

Credit: Do you understand it?

Is it the right time to refinance your mortgage?

6 questions to ask before buying a new home

Should you buy a house that’s still under construction?

5 things to avoid that can devalue your home

What is a home equity line of credit (HELOC) and what can it be used for?

Your financial aid guide: What are your options?

9 simple ways to save

3 awkward situations Zelle can help avoid

Is raising backyard chickens a good idea financially?

Here’s how to create a budget for yourself

Real world advice: How parents are teaching their kids about money

Money Moments: How to manage your finances after a divorce

Helpful tips for safe and smart charitable giving

Money Moments: 8 dos and don’ts for saving money in your 30s

Travel for less: Smart (not cheap) ways to spend less on your next trip

Understanding guardianship and power of attorney in banking

What’s in your emergency fund?

What you need to know about renting

From LLC to S-corp: Choosing a small business entity

6 things to know about long-term care insurance cost and benefits

Do I need a financial advisor?

Maximizing your infrastructure finance project with a full suite trustee and agent

6 tips for trust fund distribution to beneficiaries

Preparing for retirement: 8 steps to take

How to build wealth at any age

How to manage your money: 7 tips to improve your finances

LGBTQ+ financial planning tips

Investment strategies by age

Should I itemize my taxes?

Your 5-step guide to financial planning

What is Medicare? Understanding your coverage options

8 steps to take before you buy a home

Military homeownership: Your guide to resources, financing and more

What to know when buying a home with your significant other

Building a dream home that fits your life

Mortgage basics: How much house can you afford?

Mortgage basics: Finding the right home loan for you

Home buying myths: Realities of owning a home

Uncover the cost: Home renovation

Certificates of deposit: How they work to grow your money

5 financial goals for the new year

Retirement savings by age

Annual insurance policy review checklist

Allowance basics for parents and kids

How I did it: Turned my side hustle into a full-time job

Retirement plan options for the self-employed

Rebuilding finances after a natural disaster

5 reasons why couples may have separate bank accounts

Common unexpected expenses and three ways to pay for them

It's possible: 7 tips for breaking the spending cycle

Closing on a house checklist for buyers

How to plan and save for adoption and in vitro fertility treatment costs

Multiple accounts can make it easier to follow a monthly budget

Is it time to get a shared bank account with your partner?

Don’t underestimate the importance of balancing your checking account

7 steps to keep your personal and business finances separate

Which is better: Combining bank accounts before marriage — or after?

At your service: outsourcing loan agency work

30-day adulting challenge: Financial wellness tasks to complete in a month

Estate planning checklist: 8 steps to secure your legacy

8 steps to choosing a health insurance plan

Key milestone ages as you near and start retirement

How to build a financial plan that covers your savings and expenses

How I did it: Bought a home without a 20 percent down payment

How I did it: Switched career paths by taking an unexpected pivot

5 ways to maximize your garage sale profits 

What you need to know before buying a new or used car

Estate planning documents: Living trusts vs. will vs. living will

Why estate planning is important

How a Health Savings Account (HSA) can benefit your retirement plan

Year-end financial checklist

Housing market trends and relocation impact

An investor’s guide to marketplace lending

What is a CLO?

Beyond Mars, AeroVironment’s earthly expansion fueled by U.S. Bank

ABL mythbusters: The truth about asset-based lending

Finance or operating lease? Deciphering the legalese of equipment finance

Buying or leasing? Questions to ask before signing a contract

Collateral options for ABL: What’s eligible, what’s not?

Can ABL options fuel your business — and keep it running?

Insource or outsource? 10 considerations

The secret to successful service provider integration

Evaluating interest rate risk creating risk management strategy

Safeguarding the payment experience through contactless

COVID-19 safety recommendations: Are you ready to reopen?

Unexpected cost savings may be hiding in your payment strategy

Tech lifecycle refresh: A tale of two philosophies

Changes in credit reporting and what it means for homebuyers

High-cost housing and down payment options in relocation

4 benefits of independent loan agents

Middle-market direct lending: Obstacles and opportunities

Crypto + Relo: Mobility industry impacts

For today's relocating home buyers, time and money are everything

How to sell your business without emotions getting in the way

5 steps to take before transitioning your business

10 tips on how to run a successful family business

Streamline operations with all-in-one small business financial support

Talent acquisition 101: Building a small business dream team

How to fund your business without using 401(k) savings

Costs to consider when starting a business

How to test new business ideas

The costs of hiring a new employee

How to expand your business: Does a new location make sense?

How jumbo loans can help home buyers and your builder business

When to consider switching banks for your business

5 tips to help you land a small business loan

How to build a content team

Multigenerational household financial planning strategies

How to track expenses

How to manage your finances when you're self-employed

Good debt vs. bad debt: Know the difference

Good money habits: 6 common money mistakes to avoid

Reviewing your beneficiaries: A 5-step guide

How to talk about money with your family

Financial steps to take after the death of a spouse

Retirement advice: How to retire happy

Retirement income planning: 4 steps to take

Preparing for retirement: 8 steps to take

How I did it: Transitioned from the military to a private sector career

Working after retirement: Factors to consider

4 steps to finding a charity to support

Year end tax planning tips

Tips for navigating a medical hardship when you’re unable to work

11 essential things to do before baby comes

Webinar: Uncover the cost: Starting a family

Preparing for adoption and IVF

Checklist: 10 questions to ask your home inspector

Handling the finances of someone who has died: Terms and definitions

Resources for managing financial matters after an unexpected death

What you need to know as the executor of an estate

When your spouse has passed away: A three-month financial checklist

What documents do you need after a loved one dies?

Simple steps to be ready for a natural disaster

Checklist: financial recovery after a natural disaster

How does money influence your planning?

Student checklist: Preparing for college

The A to Z’s of college loan terms

Co-signing 101: Applying for a loan with co-borrower

Practical money skills and financial tips for college students

How to build credit as a student

5 things to know before accepting a first job offer

How I did it: Paid off student loans

Bank Notes: College cost comparison

Recognize. React. Report. Caregivers can help protect against financial exploitation

Is online banking safe?

What to do with your tax refund or bonus

Pros and cons of a personal line credit

3 tips for saving money when moving to a new home

5 tips for creating (and sticking to) a holiday budget

Planning self-care moments that matter (and how to finance them)

5 things to consider when deciding to take an unplanned trip

Stay committed to your goals by creating positive habits

Growing your savings by going on a ‘money hunt’

Working with an accountability partner can help you reach your goals

Does your savings plan match your lifestyle?

Uncover the cost: Wedding

Uncover the cost: International trip

Are savings bonds still a thing?

Tips to overcome three common savings hurdles

Adulting 101: How to make a budget plan

Personal loans first-timer's guide: 7 questions to ask

Mindset Matters: How to practice mindful spending

How can I help my student manage money?

You can take these 18 budgeting tips straight to the bank

Save time and money with automatic bill pay

Do you and your fiancé have compatible financial goals?

U.S. Bank asks: Transitioning out of college life? What’s next?

U.S. Bank asks: Do you know your finances?

Personal finance for teens can empower your child

How to save for a wedding

Dear Money Mentor: How do I set and track financial goals?

Lost job finance tips: What to do when you lose your job

Money Moments: 3 smart financial strategies when caring for aging parents

Money management guide to financial independence

7 financial questions to consider when changing jobs

How to stop living paycheck to paycheck post-pay increase

Bank from home with these digital features

How grandparents can contribute to college funds instead of buying gifts

How to open and invest in a 529 plan

Using 529 plans for K-12 tuition

Is a home equity loan for college the right choice for your student

Parent checklist: Preparing for college

How to apply for federal student aid through the FAFSA

What to consider before taking out a student loan

Are you ready to restart your federal student loan payments?

Everything you need to know about consolidating debts

How to use debt to build wealth

What’s a subordination agreement, and why does it matter?

Understanding the true cost of borrowing: What is amortization, and why does it matter?

Know your debt-to-income ratio

Your quick guide to loans and obtaining credit

Dear Money Mentor: What is cash-out refinancing and is it right for you?

Home improvements with the best ROI

Overcoming high interest rates: Getting your homeownership goals back on track

How we did it: Converted to solar power

For today's homebuyers, time and money are everything

Crypto + Homebuying: Impacts on the real estate market

How I did it: Bought my dream home using equity

Buying a home Q&A: What made three homeowners fall in love with their new home

House Hacks: How buying an investment property worked as my first home

Managing the impacts of appraisal gaps in a hot housing market

How I did it: Built living spaces to support my family

Spring cleaning checklist for your home: 5 budget-boosting tasks

Saving for a down payment: Where should I keep my money?

Your guide to breaking the rental cycle

Checklist: 6 to-dos for after a move

What are conforming loan limits and why are they increasing

Uncover the cost: Building a home

The lowdown on 6 myths about buying a home

4 ways to free up your budget (and your life) with a smaller home

Get more home for your money with these tips

Money Moments: Tips for selling your home

Money Moments: How to finance a home addition

How I did it: My house remodel

Dear Money Mentor: When should I refinance a mortgage?

Beyond the mortgage: Other costs for homeowners

10 questions to ask when hiring a contractor

What is an escrow account? Do I have one?

These small home improvement projects offer big returns on investment

Should you get a home equity loan or a home equity line of credit?

Is a home equity line of credit (HELOC) right for you?

How to use your home equity to finance home improvements

How do I prequalify for a mortgage?

Home equity: Small ways to improve the value of your home

Can you take advantage of the dead equity in your home?

4 questions to ask before you buy an investment property

10 uses for a home equity loan

Test your loan savvy

Take the stress out of buying your teen a car

Questions to ask before buying a car

How to choose the best car loan for you

Disclosures

Start of disclosure content

Loan approval is subject to credit approval and program guidelines. Not all loan programs are available in all states for all loan amounts. Interest rate and program terms are subject to change without notice. Mortgage, Home Equity and Credit products are offered through U.S. Bank National Association. Deposit products are offered through U.S. Bank National Association. Member FDIC.